Miami, FL – On August 25, a federal jury in Miami, Florida, delivered a staggering $243 million verdict against Elon Musk’s Tesla (TSLA.O) in a lawsuit over a 2019 fatal crash involving an Autopilot-equipped Model S, after the company rejected a $60 million settlement proposal, according to court filings.
The case, the first to reach trial over a wrongful death caused by Tesla’s Autopilot system, awarded $129 million in compensatory damages to the estate of Naibel Benavides Leon, who was killed, and her boyfriend Dillon Angulo, who was seriously injured, plus $200 million in punitive damages, with Tesla liable for 33% of the compensatory damages ($42.6 million) and all punitive damages.
The verdict, which Tesla plans to appeal, has sparked intense debate over autonomous driving safety and corporate accountability, set against a backdrop of political and social turmoil involving Musk’s ally, President Donald Trump.
The Verdict – A Blow to Tesla’s Autopilot
The lawsuit stemmed from a 2019 collision in Miami-Dade County, where a Tesla Model S operating on Autopilot struck a vehicle driven by Naibel Benavides Leon, 27, killing her and severely injuring Angulo, 25. The plaintiffs’ lawyers, in a Monday filing in Miami’s federal court, revealed Tesla rejected a $60 million settlement offer before trial, opting to face a jury that ultimately awarded a combined $329 million, with Tesla responsible for $242.6 million.
Jurors attributed 67% of the compensatory damages to the Tesla driver, who was not a defendant, citing his failure to override Autopilot, but held Tesla fully accountable for punitive damages due to “gross negligence” in Autopilot’s design and marketing, per the filing.
Tesla denied wrongdoing, stating in a press release, “The verdict only works to set back automotive safety and jeopardize Tesla’s and the entire industry’s efforts to develop and implement life-saving technology.”
The company argued that Autopilot, which requires driver supervision, was not defective and that the crash resulted from human error. Tesla’s appeal, expected to challenge the punitive damages, could reach the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals by early 2026.
Why It Matters
The trial, the first to address a third-party wrongful death linked to Autopilot, marks a significant setback for Tesla, which has faced scrutiny over its semi-autonomous system. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) reported 29 fatal Autopilot crashes through 2024, with ongoing investigations into 1,200 incidents involving Tesla’s Full Self-Driving (FSD) and Autopilot systems.
The plaintiffs’ attorneys, from the Buzbee Law Firm, argued Tesla’s marketing exaggerated Autopilot’s capabilities, misleading drivers into over-reliance, a claim supported by a 2024 NHTSA report criticizing Tesla’s “inadequate driver engagement monitoring.”
The $200 million punitive damages award, among the largest in a U.S. automotive case, reflects jurors’ view that Tesla prioritized innovation over safety. The plaintiffs’ filing seeks $7 million in legal fees, citing Tesla’s “reckless conduct” and the case’s complexity. Previous Autopilot lawsuits, including a 2023 California case settled for an undisclosed amount, avoided trial, making this verdict a precedent-setting moment for autonomous vehicle litigation.
Musk, Tesla, and Political Context
The verdict comes amid heightened scrutiny of Elon Musk, a former Trump ally whose xAI company is central to the administration’s July 2025 AI Action Plan, which promotes deregulated AI development. Musk’s vocal support for Trump, including a $45 million donation to the America PAC in 2024, ties Tesla’s legal battles to the political maelstrom of Trump’s second term.
On X, reactions to the verdict are polarized. Critics like @CalltoActivism posted, “Tesla’s $243M verdict shows Musk’s dangerous Autopilot hype isn’t above the law,” while supporters like @TeslaFanaticUSA argued, “This is a witch hunt—Autopilot saves lives, and the driver was 67% at fault.” The case has amplified calls for stricter autonomous vehicle regulations, with Sen. Elizabeth Warren tweeting, “Musk’s reckless tech experiments can’t keep costing lives.”
Continue Reading Below…
HOTTEST STORIES NOW
- ‘Get Your Head Out Of Trump’s A** and Impeach Him’ Fed Up Voter Blasts GOP Lawmaker – Video
- ‘I Will Not Resign’ Fed Gov Defies Trump in Explosive Clash: ‘You Don’t Have the Authority’ to ‘Fire Me’
- John Bolton Exposes Trump’s Alarming Health Secrets Just One Week Before FBI Raid
What’s Next?
The verdict could reshape Tesla’s Autopilot strategy, with analysts predicting a $2 billion stock value hit if upheld, per Bloomberg. It may spur tighter NHTSA regulations, with a proposed 2026 rule requiring enhanced driver monitoring.
Tesla’s appeal, expected to argue excessive punitive damages, faces a high bar, as Florida courts rarely overturn jury awards unless procedural errors are clear, per legal expert David Weinstein in Law360.
MORE: Trump’s Hands Now Covered in Bruises, Renewing Health Fears
Discover more from Local Stories
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.