Miami Beach, FL – On August 21, Miriam Shvetz, a 34-year-old Florida woman, was arrested and charged with two counts of child neglect without great bodily harm after her two young children, aged 5 and 9, were found living alone in deplorable conditions in her Collins Avenue condominium, according to Miami-Dade County court records.
Shvetz, who smirks in her booking photo, was arrested after a 911 call from her ex-husband, who discovered their children unattended after dropping them off. The case, set against the backdrop of an ongoing custody dispute, has sparked outrage over the children’s welfare and highlighted broader issues of parental responsibility and child protection in Florida.
The Incident – Children Left in Filth at Miami Beach Condo
The incident unfolded on Thursday, August 21, when Shvetz’s ex-husband dropped off their 5-year-old daughter and 9-year-old son at her Miami Beach condo around noon. He told police he was unaware Shvetz would not be home, as she had not informed him of her absence during prior communication. After the children notified him that their mother was not present, he called 911, prompting a response from the Miami Beach Police Department.
Upon arrival, officers encountered a distressing scene. One officer overheard a child crying during a video call with Shvetz, who confirmed her ex-husband’s role in dropping off the children but stated she was “unable to return home immediately because she had things to do,” per the arrest report.
The condo’s condition was alarming, “Officers noted that the apartment smelled of rotting food and urine. The walls and floors were filthy and the kitchen had old food and dirty dishes scattered throughout, with flies and insects. One of the toilets was clogged and full of old urine and feces. Feces [were] also scattered throughout the bathroom floor.”
The children, left unsupervised in this environment, were not enrolled in school, unlike their 7-year-old sibling, who attends school under their father’s care. The father told investigators he is working to enroll the 5- and 9-year-olds, highlighting Shvetz’s alleged neglect of their education.
Custody Dispute and Prior Police Involvement
The case is rooted in a contentious custody battle between Shvetz and her ex-husband, which began after their 2022 divorce filing and escalated into a formal dispute in 2023. Police noted multiple prior calls to Shvetz’s residence related to custody issues, indicating a pattern of conflict. The father’s proactive steps to enroll the children in school contrast with Shvetz’s alleged inaction, raising questions about her fitness as a custodial parent.
Shvetz was arrested on August 21 and released from Miami-Dade County Jail after posting a $2,500 bond, with her arraignment scheduled for September 19, 2025, per court records. If convicted, she faces up to seven years per count of child neglect under Florida Statute 827.03, though the “no great bodily harm” designation may lessen penalties.
Why It Matters
The case has sparked significant attention on X, where reactions reflect polarized views. Users like @MiamiMomX pressed for harsher penalties, posting, “How do you leave kids in a condo like that? Miriam Shvetz needs to face real consequences.” Others, like @SunshineDad305, emphasized the father’s role, noting, “Props to the dad for stepping up—those kids deserve better.”
The incident has also fueled discussions about Florida’s child welfare system, with critics citing a 2024 Florida Department of Children and Families report showing a 15% rise in neglect cases since 2020.
Florida, under Governor Ron DeSantis, has faced criticism for its child welfare policies, with a 2025 ACLU report highlighting underfunded social services contributing to cases like Shvetz’s. The state’s focus on “parental rights” laws, championed by DeSantis, has sparked debate, with critics like Rep. Anna Eskamani (D-FL) arguing they divert resources from child protection.
Community Impact and Systemic Issues
The conditions described in Shvetz’s condo—rotting food, urine-soaked floors, and scattered feces—have shocked Miami Beach, a city known for its vibrant tourism but struggling with socioeconomic disparities.
The Collins Avenue condo, located in a high-end area, shows the hidden nature of neglect cases, which a 2024 Miami-Dade County report notes are 20% more prevalent in affluent neighborhoods than previously assumed. Community advocates, like those from Kristi House, are calling for increased social worker interventions, citing Florida’s 1,200-child caseloads per worker, triple the national average.
The case also shows the role of family dynamics in neglect. The ongoing custody dispute, detailed in court filings, reveals Shvetz’s ex-husband’s efforts to secure stable schooling for their children, contrasting with her alleged negligence. This disparity has prompted calls for stricter oversight of custody agreements, with experts like University of Miami’s Dr. Amy McCart suggesting mandatory welfare checks in high-conflict cases.
Continue Reading Below…
HOTTEST STORIES NOW
- Space Force Sergeant Sentenced to 54 Years for Killing Teen in Colorado Car Break-In Shooting
- No Jail for Wisconsin Nurse Who Cut Off Man’s Foot Without Permission to Use as Frostbite Prop
- Texas Man Kills 3 at Target, Then Claims He Acted as ‘Jesus’ to ‘Set Everyone Free’
What’s Next?
Shvetz’s September 19 arraignment will determine the next steps, with potential outcomes ranging from probation to jail time, depending on evidence of intent and harm.
The children are now with their father, who is pursuing full custody, per court documents, but the case’s resolution hinges on whether Shvetz can demonstrate compliance with parenting requirements. Florida’s Department of Children and Families is investigating, with a report due by October.
Discover more from Local Stories
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.